Marking and fairness
AI should never be the only marker. Here is what it should do instead.
In January 2026 Ofqual set out its view on AI in marking. The core of it is short: using AI as the only marker of a regulated qualification does not comply with its rules. It also said where it sees promise: checking the quality of human marking, and training new markers.
We think the line is in the right place. Not because the technology is weak, but because of what a mark is for.
A mark is a decision someone stands behind
When a pupil asks why they got 4 out of 6, a teacher has to be able to answer. When a parent challenges a grade, someone has to own the decision. "The software decided" is not an answer a school can give.
So how do you give teachers their time back without giving the decision away? This is how we built EnlightMark.
- Read first, then mark. We turn the handwriting into text before anything is marked, and keep the two steps apart. If a mark is wrong, you can see whether we misread the pupil or misjudged the answer. Those are different problems with different fixes.
- Every mark points at something. Each mark is tied to the marking point it met and the words in the answer that met it. A teacher checking a mark is checking a claim, not a number.
- Uncertain answers go to a person. When the writing is unclear, or the answer sits between two marks, it is flagged. Teachers check the flagged answers rather than every answer. That is where the time comes back.
- Nothing reaches a pupil until a teacher releases it. Teachers choose when results go out and can hold back any pupil they want to speak to first.
- The department's rules win. If a department has agreed that a correct answer with no working scores full marks, that is the rule we mark to.
And in the lesson?
Classwork is the one place feedback reaches a pupil before a teacher reads it, because feedback that waits until tomorrow cannot change today's work. Even there, every piece of feedback is checked for tone and safeguarding first, and the teacher approves the final mark after the lesson. The mark is still the teacher's.
What AI is good for
Marking is where much of a teacher's time goes, and where consistency is hardest. Ofqual's own research found examiners matched the definitive mark on about 95% of physics questions and about half of English literature questions. A careful first pass, checked by a person, can make marking faster and more consistent at once.
It can also see what one marker cannot: the question most of the class misunderstood, or the set marked more harshly than the one next door.
That is the job. Do the first pass, show the working, send the hard cases to a person, and leave the decision with the teacher.